« | Home | Categories | »

How the NSA Threatens National Security – Bruce Schneier

Posted on January 7th, 2014 at 19:34 by John Sinteur in category: News -- Write a comment


It’s not just domestic abuse we have to worry about; it’s the rest of the world, too. The more we choose to eavesdrop on the Internet and other communications technologies, the less we are secure from eavesdropping by others. Our choice isn’t between a digital world where the NSA can eavesdrop and one where the NSA is prevented from eavesdropping; it’s between a digital world that is vulnerable to all attackers, and one that is secure for all users.

Fixing this problem is going to be hard. We are long past the point where simple legal interventions can help. The bill in Congress to limit NSA surveillance won’t actually do much to limit NSA surveillance. Maybe the NSA will figure out an interpretation of the law that will allow it to do what it wants anyway. Maybe it’ll do it another way, using another justification. Maybe the FBI will do it and give it a copy. And when asked, it’ll lie about it.

NSA-level surveillance is like the Maginot Line was in the years before World War II: ineffective and wasteful. We need to openly disclose what surveillance we have been doing, and the known insecurities that make it possible. We need to work toward security, even if other countries like China continue to use the Internet as a giant surveillance platform. We need to build a coalition of free-world nations dedicated to a secure global Internet, and we need to continually push back against bad actors—both state and non-state—that work against that goal.

  1. Remember Sony arguing that VCRs should have playback capability only? That’s what Schneier sounds like to me.

  2. Almost. In that analogy I think Schneier says that we should do all we can to only give the NSA playback capability, and golly, good for them if they can get more, but no reason to go out of our way to give them that.

previous post: Spanish?

next post: ‘I was told by police that I could be arrested. It was terrifying’